Image of the PJM Medal
Banner Text = Fight For the Right to Wear the Pingat Jasa Malaysia Medal
Reply to topic Page 1 of 1
"Battle for Australia Day"
Author Message
Reply with quote
Post "Battle for Australia Day" 
"The Australian"

Battle won on dedicated Pacific war day

Patrick Walters, National security editor | June 26, 2008

AFTER a long campaign by the RSL and a group of dedicated World War II Pacific veterans, the Rudd Government will today officially declare the first Wednesday in September "Battle for Australia Day".

Veterans Affairs Minister Alan Griffin will announce the new official commemoration, which marks the year 1942, when Australia thwarted Japan's southward advance into New Guinea and the Coral Sea.

Governor-General Michael Jeffery officially proclaimed "Battle for Australia Day" as a national day of observance in a proclamation published in yesterday's Commonwealth Gazette.

The idea for a special Battle for Australia Day commemoration was first raised more than a decade ago by the RSL with the veterans' organisation wanting a sharper focus on the momentous events of 1942 in the southwest Pacific.

While the proposal won in-principle endorsement from the Howard government, it has been strongly challenged by mainstream military historians who reject the formal notion of a "Battle for Australia".

"We are commemorating a battle which did not occur. Australians want to commemorate their wartime experience, but they have chosen the wrong vehicle," leading military historian Peter Stanley told The Australian last night.

Dr Stanley, the author of a book to be published next week on the battle for Australia, says the new "revisionist" view of 1942 has never figured in general histories of Australia or in specialist studies of the Pacific war.

The RSL has cited a speech by wartime prime minister John Curtin in February 1942 as the inspiration for the concept.

At that time, Curtin said the fall of Singapore "opens the battle for Australia".

The RSL and the unofficial Battle for Australia Council has wanted to see much more visible recognition of the series of 1942 battles against the Japanese, including the initial victory at Milne Bay in early 1942 followed by the battle of the Coral Sea and the Kokoda campaign.

"As it turned out, Curtin was wrong. There was to be no such battle, not as he envisaged it," Dr Stanley says.

There is no battle honour "Battle for Australia" inscribed on any army regimental colour or ship's crest and the phrase then disappeared for 50 years until the mid-1990s revival.

According to the Battle for Australia Council website, the battles in which Japanese forces were expelled from Australian territory is still relatively unknown to the wider public.

"It was a struggle that stretched our national resources to the limit; which saw the bombing of mainland Australia; the attack by midget submarines on Sydney Harbour; and raised the spectre of the threat of a possible invasion through Papua New Guinea," the website says.


_________________
Merdeka, Merdeka, Merdeka,
from the HD Committee and its decision.
View user's profile Send private message
Reply with quote
Post Battle for Australia 
Interesting to think that the 'historians' were not born till after the war and have no first hand knowledge of those events.

Furthermore, veterans have a marked reluctance to talk about their experiences outside of their peer group, fearful of being labled 'fanciful' or muddled in their recollections.

If 'historians' were true historians, they would have gleaned all military records to the point of exhaustion to ascertain the facts. Sadly they have not done so in this case, which leaves veterans bitter and resentful that their sacrifices have been in vain... with a caveat of course, that the Japanese never conquored Australia.

Recollection and memorial are an integral part of the healing process, and a country remembering those that made the ultimate sacrifice, is a visible thanks to them and to those that survived.

To find any reason not to honour them, is churlish to say but the least.

Yours Aye

Arthur

View user's profile Send private message
Display posts from previous:
Reply to topic Page 1 of 1
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum